“The Digital Mirage: Why Your Kenyan Business' Online Marketing Isn’t Working (Yet)”

With everyone and their auntie going online, many businesses in Africa have rushed to embrace digital marketing as the silver bullet. The narrative sounds compelling: set up a Facebook page, post on Instagram, run some Google or Facebook ads, and watch the customers roll in. Unfortunately, the reality is not so simple. For many, digital marketing has turned out to be a mirage – it looks promising from afar, but when you get there, you find little to no water (or in this case, little to no results). Why does digital often fail, especially in our context?

1. Poor Targeting: Digital platforms themselves are powerful in their targeting capabilities – you can zero in on users by location, interests, age, etc. – but that only helps if you know who your target is and how to reach them. A common mistake is the “spray and pray” approach, where businesses target too broadly or even leave Facebook’s default settings (which might target a global audience by mistake!). Imagine a boutique hotel in Nakuru intending to attract local tourists, but their boosted Facebook post is going out to people in North America or to teenagers who can’t afford a vacation. That’s wasted money. In Africa, we’ve seen many SMEs boost posts without a clear audience in mind, resulting in thousands of impressions in far-flung places or to uninterested viewers. The tools were there, but the strategy was not – leading to dismal outcomes.

2. Irrelevant or Low-Quality Content: Even when the targeting is right, what you show people matters immensely. This is where content comes in. Many digital campaigns fail because the content is boring, overly salesy, or not tailored to the audience. For instance, a real estate company might post a generic ad saying, “Beautiful 3BR houses for sale – call now!” with a stock photo. Compare that to an ad that shows a short video tour of the house, with a happy family walking through the living room, talking about how this is the home where their kids will grow up. The first is just a bland sales pitch; the second is a story that tugs at emotions. If your content doesn’t speak to the viewer, they’ll scroll past it. In Africa, where cultural relevance is key, content that looks copy-pasted from a Western template (and doesn’t reflect local realities or aspirations) is often ignored. People respond to content that feels real to them.

3. Low Engagement and “Ad Blindness”: Over the past years, internet users worldwide – and Kenyans are no exception – have developed what’s known as banner blindness. This is when people consciously or unconsciously ignore anything that looks like an ad on a webpage or app​adpushup.com. Think about your own behavior: when a YouTube ad pops up, you look for the “Skip” button as fast as possible. When scrolling a news site, you might mentally tune out the sponsored banners. This learned behavior means that even if your ad is on someone’s screen, there’s a good chance it’s not registering in their mind. The result? Dismal engagement rates. For example, the average click-through rate (CTR) for Facebook ads across industries is around 1% – meaning 99% of people who see an ad do not click it. If your content or targeting is off, expect even worse. We’ve all seen posts with “0 likes, 0 comments” – a clear sign of content that’s just not hitting the mark. Low engagement not only means the campaign is failing, but it also hurts future reach because social algorithms show content that people engage with. No engagement = invisibility in the digital realm.

4. Mistrust of Ads: There’s an old joke: “Don’t believe everything you see on the internet.” Consumers have grown skeptical of online ads and for good reason. With the proliferation of scams and clickbait, people are cautious. A global Nielsen survey found that 88% of people trust recommendations from people they know over any form of advertising​nielsen.com. Even in Africa, where trust in community is high, trust in advertisements (especially online ones) is relatively low. If a random ad claims “Best prices in town!”, the default reaction might be doubt – “Says who? That’s what everyone says.” But if a friend or local influencer vouches for a product, that’s different. This mistrust means that just because you put out an ad doesn’t mean people believe it or will act on it. Digital platforms are rife with exaggerated claims, so consumers have their guard up.

5. The Illusion of “Free” or Easy Marketing: Another aspect of the digital mirage is the assumption that marketing online is free or cheap. It’s true that setting up a Facebook page or Twitter account costs nothing. But getting results from digital marketing either costs money (for ads, tools, or hiring skilled people) or time and creativity (to produce great content and engage). Many SMEs start enthusiastically by posting a few times on social media and then give up when the phone doesn’t start ringing. The truth is, an abandoned Facebook page with a dozen posts is about as effective as a billboard in the desert. Without consistent effort and resources, digital marketing won’t yield fruit. And if you do throw money at it without a plan (like boosting posts arbitrarily), it can even lose you money.

So, we have a paradox: we know audiences are online (from the previous section), yet going online doesn’t automatically equate to success. Digital marketing is not a plug-and-play solution, especially not in Africa where audience behavior might differ from the West and where trust and relevance are hard-earned. The mirage is thinking that being on digital platforms is enough. The reality is that you have to approach digital marketing strategically and thoughtfully, blending the art of great storytelling with the science of targeting and analytics.

The good news? When you do digital right – with meaningful content, proper targeting, and a human touch – it can work wonders. We have a perfect example of that in our case study later, where a small campsite achieved unbelievable results through smart digital marketing. But before we get there, let’s demystify what does work. If the old ways are waning and the new ways require skill, what’s the formula that businesses can rely on? The next section lays out the ingredients for marketing success in today’s environment.

Check out our elite marketing services!

Join our official community for more!